U.S. Education Policy: What the Potential Dismantling of the Department of Education Means for Students

bonniechen54
Apr 2, 2025
4 min read

The Education Department Under Fire: Impacts for Domestic and International Students

A series of sweeping changes proposed by the Trump administration in early 2025 has reignited a national debate about the role of the U.S. Department of Education. Among the most controversial actions: mass layoffs, AI outsourcing of call center functions, halted civil rights investigations, and calls to dismantle the department entirely. While supporters argue for smaller government and local control, educators and lawmakers warn these moves could have serious consequences for both domestic and international students.

With over $79 billion in the Department of Education’s annual budget, the question looms: what happens to millions of students if this federal backbone is removed?

Dismantling the Department of Education – What’s Really at Stake?

According to USA Today, top Senate Democrats recently sent a letter to Education Secretary Barry McMahon demanding answers over staff terminations and policy rollbacks, particularly concerning special education protections and civil rights cases. The administration's proposed restructure has already paused hundreds of investigations into school discrimination, disability access, and antisemitism.

Meanwhile, Higher Ed Dive reports that nearly 2,000 employees are facing layoffs, drastically reducing the department’s capacity to provide oversight and federal guidance to schools nationwide.

At the same time, The Hill reveals that the department has begun replacing human-operated federal student aid call centers with AI, through a contract rumored to involve Elon Musk’s AI firm. The backlash has been swift, with concerns over data privacy, lack of human empathy, and misinformation impacting millions of students and families who rely on these resources.

How These Changes Impact Domestic and International Students

Federal Student Aid at Risk

For domestic students, particularly those from low-income backgrounds, the department’s rollback could mean delays—or even disruptions—in accessing FAFSA processing, Pell Grants, and loan forgiveness. Many fear that the move to AI-managed systems will create errors and confusion for first-generation college students.

For international students, the effects could be even more destabilizing. The Department of Education oversees institutional accreditation, which in turn affects student visa eligibility and recognition of degrees. A weakened or decentralized education department could create discrepancies in standards across states, complicating how international degrees are validated globally.

Education Professionals Sound the Alarm

Senator Elizabeth Warren has been one of the most vocal critics, launching the “Save Our Schools” campaign in response to these developments. “This isn’t just about budget cuts,” she said. “It’s about abandoning millions of students who rely on federal protections and resources to access a fair education.”

Civil rights experts echo her concerns. According to AP News, investigations into antisemitic incidents, racial discrimination, and disability accommodations have been stalled indefinitely. Without federal enforcement, schools may no longer be held accountable for civil rights violations, disproportionately affecting marginalized student populations.

Upcoming Challenges for International Students

International students in the U.S. may face a particularly complex future if the Department of Education is dismantled or stripped of its core functions:

Loss of Consistent Policy Guidance: The department currently ensures that U.S. education standards align with global expectations. Its absence may lead to fragmented, state-by-state standards, making it harder for international degrees to hold value abroad.
Accreditation Confusion: International students must often prove their U.S. degrees come from accredited institutions to apply for jobs or graduate programs overseas. If the federal role in accreditation is diminished, this could impact job prospects and student mobility.
Visa Implications: International student visas (F-1, M-1) are often tied to institutions recognized by the Department of Education. Any disruption in accreditation or program verification could jeopardize students’ legal status.

Public Response and What’s Next

The public response has been polarized. Some conservative groups welcome the dismantling as a move toward local control, while many educators, parents, and students are worried about the loss of federal oversight in areas like civil rights, special education, and financial aid.

Senate Democrats have asked the Inspector General to investigate the department’s recent decisions, especially the sudden layoffs and halting of disability cases. Meanwhile, universities and school districts are preparing contingency plans should the department’s capacity continue to shrink.

Conclusion: What Families and Students Should Know Moving Forward

The Department of Education’s uncertain future has immediate and long-term implications for millions of students. Whether you're a domestic student navigating federal aid or an international student trying to maintain visa status and degree legitimacy, staying informed is more important than ever.

Students and families should:

Monitor university communications about federal aid and accreditation
Stay updated on visa regulations through official DHS and SEVP channels
Advocate for federal protections, especially for vulnerable student groups
Seek professional guidance for financial aid and immigration planning

As education policy continues to shift, understanding the role of federal oversight—and what might happen without it—is critical for every student planning to study in the U.S.

Sources: